Buddhism
Q&A for people practicing or interested in Buddhist philosophy, teaching, and practice
Latest Questions
0
votes
0
answers
15
views
The "Aha!" moment: From conceptual knowledge to direct vision (dassana)?
I’ve been reflecting on ***the slide*** of the practice—that threshold where the "Doer" or the "Agent" seems to fall away and you’re just left with the flow of the process. Suttas like **AN 11.2 (the Cetana Sutta)** describe this beautifully. They show the path as a series of mental qualities that "...
I’ve been reflecting on ***the slide*** of the practice—that threshold where the "Doer" or the "Agent" seems to fall away and you’re just left with the flow of the process.
Suttas like **AN 11.2 (the Cetana Sutta)** describe this beautifully. They show the path as a series of mental qualities that "flow on and fill up" through dhammatā (natural law), without needing an act of will (cetanā) to push them along.
It's one thing to know the "map" of these links intellectually, but I'm curious about the specific point where that knowledge flips into a direct "Aha!" moment—witnessing the mechanics run themselves. How do the Suttas (or the broader tradition) describe this shift from just knowing the mechanics (ñāṇa) to actually seeing them unfold (dassana)? Is there a specific term for that tipping point?
Newton
(294 rep)
Jan 14, 2026, 03:26 PM
0
votes
3
answers
118
views
Struggling with Japanese skin versus Caucasian skin
Caucasian skin is peachy and sandy (due to having no pigmentation) while the great man's body in nibbana is, according to [the 32 perfections of a great man][1], "his skin is the color of gold". White skin requires some pigmentation. Currently my journey with white skin represents the Trix rabbit's...
Caucasian skin is peachy and sandy (due to having no pigmentation) while the great man's body in nibbana is, according to the 32 perfections of a great man , "his skin is the color of gold". White skin requires some pigmentation.
Currently my journey with white skin represents the Trix rabbit's (1994 commercial) attempt to take his own cereal. All he gets is "silly rabbit Trix are for kids!" And the fact that some saints may have received such a miracle to change their skin color forever makes the pain that much more serious.
And what should I do regarding the psychologist? I am visiting one to drain my emotions of this, and that might make my eternity as a yellow man all that much more permanent!
BetterOffAlone
(169 rep)
Jul 12, 2025, 12:01 AM
• Last activity: Jan 12, 2026, 08:30 AM
0
votes
0
answers
96
views
What is personality view?
Thoughts about mine and that things should be this way, about children, husband, and relatives - these are all personality view. That is developed in our own mind. So we inflicted our own wounds. So we were in our own prison. So when this thinking stops, personality view has been destroyed. Hasn't i...
Thoughts about mine and that things should be this way, about children, husband, and relatives - these are all personality view. That is developed in our own mind. So we inflicted our own wounds. So we were in our own prison. So when this thinking stops, personality view has been destroyed. Hasn't it?
Buddhika
(21 rep)
Aug 5, 2025, 08:53 AM
• Last activity: Jan 6, 2026, 03:11 AM
1
votes
3
answers
136
views
Who is mindful?
If there is no self in mental formations and volition, then who carries out mindfulness? I try to see that there is no self in things. Is it not therefore that I am? 'Being mindful you'll see that even the ambition to be mindful has no self' - who sees that?
If there is no self in mental formations and volition, then who carries out mindfulness?
I try to see that there is no self in things. Is it not therefore that I am?
'Being mindful you'll see that even the ambition to be mindful has no self' - who sees that?
Gondola Spärde
(461 rep)
Aug 6, 2025, 12:23 PM
• Last activity: Jan 3, 2026, 10:10 PM
0
votes
1
answers
95
views
"unshaken, serene, at ease, uninvolved" as a mindful reminder throughout my day?
Definitions: - I want to emphasize the mind, the body doesn't ache, isn't sore, isn't itchy, nothing at all; that is the 'an lạc' of the body (bodily ease/well-being). - 'Thanh thản' (serenity) is when our mind doesn't ponder, isn't busy at all; that is 'thanh thản'. - 'Vô sự' (actionlessness/n...
Definitions:
- I want to emphasize the mind, the body doesn't ache, isn't sore, isn't itchy, nothing at all; that is the 'an lạc' of the body (bodily ease/well-being).
- 'Thanh thản' (serenity) is when our mind doesn't ponder, isn't busy at all; that is 'thanh thản'.
- 'Vô sự' (actionlessness/nothing-to-do) is doing nothing at all; the body also does nothing, and the mind also doesn't ponder, meaning it does nothing; that is 'vô sự'. It is normal, very normal like a normal person, yet doing nothing at all. That is: the head/mind doesn't work, and the hands and feet also don't work; that is 'vô sự'.
As for the mind that doesn't ponder, doesn't worry about anything at all, that is 'thanh thản' (serenity).
As for the body that doesn't ache, isn't sore, itchy, nothing at all, that is 'an lạc' (ease); it is normal. Just like right now, [if] our body has no aches or pains, that is the 'an lạc' of our body. That is the state right now; it's not anything strange or different. It is the normalcy of a normal human being.
Therefore, once you recognize that normalcy, now you just need to use the method of Right Thinking (Như Lý Tác Ý), guide it [the mind]:
> "A mind unshaken, serene, at ease, and free from involvement.”
You just fear it [the mind] will move and ponder about this and that, so you remind it: ‘Mind immovable, serene, at ease, actionless,’ and then just sit relaxedly/idly like that.
So, can I use "unshaken, serene, at ease, uninvolved" as a mindful reminder throughout my day to make my mind feel better?
LindaBMT85
(53 rep)
May 5, 2025, 04:01 AM
• Last activity: Dec 26, 2025, 09:29 AM
4
votes
5
answers
175
views
Is identifying with the good always a problem?
When a person or a group of people identify themselves with "the good" (in opposition to "not so good" or even "the evil" of others), quite often this can lead to "the good" getting overly aggressive in its pursuit of the goodness and de-facto turning into evil. Is this an inevitable problem arising...
When a person or a group of people identify themselves with "the good" (in opposition to "not so good" or even "the evil" of others), quite often this can lead to "the good" getting overly aggressive in its pursuit of the goodness and de-facto turning into evil.
Is this an inevitable problem arising due to identification/reification or is there a way to keep it under control and identify with the good without becoming the evil? If so, how can that be achieved?
What guidelines do various Buddhist schools offer on this topic, if any?
P.S. by "to identify with" I mean "to consider themselves to be affiliated with, or to be representative of, the true *something* (in this case *the good*)"
Andriy Volkov
(59751 rep)
Apr 7, 2022, 04:20 PM
• Last activity: Dec 24, 2025, 03:28 AM
1
votes
2
answers
65
views
How to practice the brahmavihara of Metta?
What practise to do to fill your heart with Metta? What kind of meditation or what to do the meditation?
What practise to do to fill your heart with Metta? What kind of meditation or what to do the meditation?
The White Cloud
(2410 rep)
Dec 20, 2025, 03:10 PM
• Last activity: Dec 21, 2025, 05:10 PM
2
votes
4
answers
134
views
What is the purpose of idol worship in buddhism? Does the buddha help?
I come from Hindu background. Hindus do idol worship in the temples and also there are idols in home. There are elaborate rituals about how to do the worship. The core belief in hindusim is that if you worship the idol then that particular diety will grant wishes, fulfill desires and give boons to f...
I come from Hindu background. Hindus do idol worship in the temples and also there are idols in home. There are elaborate rituals about how to do the worship. The core belief in hindusim is that if you worship the idol then that particular diety will grant wishes, fulfill desires and give boons to fulfill the desires in samsara. Almost 90% of how hinduism is practised is along the lines of pleasing the diety.
However the central tenet of Buddhism is to get rid of desires and desiring mind. "Desire is the cause of sorrow" the Buddha said. So, My question is why do Buddhist also do idol worship. There are temples of the Buddha where there are Buddha statues and also there are rituals in front of the Buddha statue.
When asked 'if the Buddha exist after the Mahaparinirvana?' The Buddha did not answer the question. Nirvana means 'blown out', 'extinguished. My question is, does the Buddha help in any way to the devotees of the Buddha. Does the Buddha help solve the problems in Samsara? How does the worshipping of the Buddha help the Buddhist on the path? Is there some part of Buddha, perhaps His consciousness gets accessed through the statue?
The White Cloud
(2410 rep)
Dec 5, 2025, 02:40 PM
• Last activity: Dec 21, 2025, 04:38 PM
2
votes
2
answers
49
views
Which brahmavihara is the most easy to practise?
Of the 4 brahmaviharas, karuna, metta, mudita and uppekha, which is the most easy to practise?
Of the 4 brahmaviharas, karuna, metta, mudita and uppekha, which is the most easy to practise?
The White Cloud
(2410 rep)
Dec 20, 2025, 03:08 PM
• Last activity: Dec 21, 2025, 04:10 PM
1
votes
1
answers
28
views
How to practice the brahmavihara of Karuna?
I want to cultivate the brahmavihara of Karuna (compassion). How to meditate or what practise to generate the heart of Karuna?
I want to cultivate the brahmavihara of Karuna (compassion). How to meditate or what practise to generate the heart of Karuna?
The White Cloud
(2410 rep)
Dec 20, 2025, 03:01 PM
• Last activity: Dec 20, 2025, 09:05 PM
0
votes
2
answers
284
views
How to decrease crave in daily-life?
In theory, many ways of meditation have been given to stop cravings and aversion. What about practical life? During day to day life, it has often been seen and experienced as well that, "we tend to lean towards comfortablity", whether it be of body or brain. Let's take a basic example: one living in...
In theory, many ways of meditation have been given to stop cravings and aversion.
What about practical life?
During day to day life, it has often been seen and experienced as well that, "we tend to lean towards comfortablity", whether it be of body or brain.
Let's take a basic example: one living in a rented house tend to go for a own-home(whenever possible).... even monks of modern era tend to go for own-kuti/monastery. For this one needs money. Reason being given is, "i feel more freedom inside my own-home instead of rented one".
Another eg. : Using technologies, more resources for making life easy-going. Resaon being given as: we have less headaches, more respect, easy-flow of society.
Even if i properly give time to analyze, realize, etc. bhlabhla, stay *disconnected* to this modernized life, there is definitely no need for me to ask this question!
If one doesn't go for maintaining status, using hi-fi techs, spending money(either for dana purpose or for anything else..), ........ It's more likely to be 99.99% that such person would be physically and mentally **behind** from others.
One simple solution came is:: live like a bpl(below poverty line) person but this will definitely decrease morale and enthusiasm of nearby-ones, decreasing their chances of learning dhamma.
(If possible, kindly don't include advice for meditation to a freak and too-ignorants)
i am more concerned into balancing the life(middle path for householders) such that both nearby ones and me can have less possible crave, more possible dhamma!
**Edit::**
Maybe, this answer is somewhat talking about balance in last 3 paragraphs. But it is also saying to re-engage in earning money to get approval of others.....getting approval is ok but how would money change someone's behaviour, confusing to me?
user17680
Feb 12, 2020, 07:17 AM
• Last activity: Dec 13, 2025, 05:01 AM
0
votes
2
answers
76
views
Practical example of paramattha dhamma compared to samutti
Please give a clear simple example of how this looks in a practical way without quoting suttas. I just want a practical example. Thanks > The object of consciousness, or mind-object, that arises has to be of > ultimate reality, not conventional reality. We must be able to > differentiate between wha...
Please give a clear simple example of how this looks in a practical way without quoting suttas. I just want a practical example. Thanks
> The object of consciousness, or mind-object, that arises has to be of
> ultimate reality, not conventional reality. We must be able to
> differentiate between what is absolute reality, or paramattha dhamma
> and what is conventional reality, or sammuti.
Sati
(728 rep)
Apr 29, 2024, 02:44 AM
• Last activity: Nov 21, 2025, 02:03 PM
1
votes
2
answers
139
views
How can I rectify my past mistakes?
I am basically an Undergraduate student in India. Let me tell everyone that I made huge mistakes in my past. When my parents beat me, I also beat them. I never respected my parents and my teachers. Whenever my parents told me to touch the feet of the elders, I always used to get angry at my parents....
I am basically an Undergraduate student in India.
Let me tell everyone that I made huge mistakes in my past. When my parents beat me, I also beat them. I never respected my parents and my teachers. Whenever my parents told me to touch the feet of the elders, I always used to get angry at my parents. Whenever my parents suggested me anything good, then I always used to get angry and many times I have even beaten my parents. I have never said "Thank You Sir" to my teachers when they helped me out with my Doubts. I always used to challenge my elders. Many times, I have even shouted at my grandparents.
But now at the age of 21, I am able to understand my every mistakes which I already committed in the past. Now I want to rectify myselves. I really want to know that how can I rectify myselves ? How can I control my anger ?
Bachelor
(133 rep)
Nov 14, 2025, 12:45 PM
• Last activity: Nov 15, 2025, 06:10 PM
0
votes
2
answers
64
views
What does "picking up the aggregates" mean, and does it apply in this example?
In my quest to develop virtue, sometimes, I get distracted and entangled in thoughts. When I am in thoughts, virtuous conduct is halted. The reason why I get entangled in thoughts, is usually because of attachment. For example, attachment to what someone thinks about me. My head starts ruminating an...
In my quest to develop virtue, sometimes, I get distracted and entangled in thoughts. When I am in thoughts, virtuous conduct is halted.
The reason why I get entangled in thoughts, is usually because of attachment. For example, attachment to what someone thinks about me. My head starts ruminating and I am not being mindful or diligent or metta in the present moment.
One way to phrase this came to mind, inspired by a sutta describing enlightenment.
To paraphrase the relevant part of the sutta:
> Picking up the aggregates is a burden, laying them down is blissful
Inspired by this, **when I become distracted, I think of it like this:**
> **Instead of having practiced the eightfold path, I picked up the aggregates**
**Since I still don't grasp enlightenment or anatta, I am unsure if this is a helpful application of that phrase.**
What do you think?
Gondola Spärde
(461 rep)
Nov 13, 2025, 12:47 PM
• Last activity: Nov 14, 2025, 11:29 PM
0
votes
2
answers
55
views
Is this a valid way to casually phrase identification with aggregates?
**Today I momentarily fell back to identifying with old thinking patterns, and as a result, old habits and sluggishness emerged.** It caused some trouble, mainly that I delayed departure to a casual meeting with my parents. I called and said as an explanation that I don't feel so good today, and the...
**Today I momentarily fell back to identifying with old thinking patterns, and as a result, old habits and sluggishness emerged.** It caused some trouble, mainly that I delayed departure to a casual meeting with my parents.
I called and said as an explanation that I don't feel so good today, and the way I said it left open interpretation that I may call things off entirely.
**But then, I remembered the virtue of diligence amongst others, and turned things around.**
While I told my parents that "I didn't feel so good", to myself, now, **I think of it as me having "forgotten who I am, for a moment".**
This was a phrase that came to me when I was being diligent and discarding of wrong thought again.
**But since I still don't grasp anatta, I am unsure if this is a helpful phrase.**
What do you think?
Gondola Spärde
(461 rep)
Nov 9, 2025, 02:29 PM
• Last activity: Nov 10, 2025, 06:49 PM
1
votes
2
answers
78
views
Should practice of eightfold path be seen as self?
Should I see right practice as not self? The same question is phrased three times over, in different ways, below. As context, I am a householder that seeks to eliminate suffering. **Question from Buddhist point of view** I want to let go of everything but right practice. This allows me to see many t...
Should I see right practice as not self?
The same question is phrased three times over, in different ways, below.
As context, I am a householder that seeks to eliminate suffering.
**Question from Buddhist point of view**
I want to let go of everything but right practice. This allows me to see many things as not self, unphased. For example, feeling tired or aroused or discontent. These things are not part of right practice, so I am able to see them as not self and let them pass by. It then feels like a wave has passed by me, and fully knowing that the wave was not self, and fully footed in overcoming craving, I feel no need to look back at the wave.
However, when thoughts of diligence come up, and of right speech, I am hesitant to see them as not self. I am afraid that if I see them as something that will just pass, something to be impassionate about, that I will then deviate from the right path.
The concept of right path too, is something I am hesitant to see as not self.
How to proceed?
**Question with Christian example**
In Christianity, there is the concept of the new man and the old man. Practitioners are said to never be able to hope to shake off the old man in them (until Jesus returns). Practitioners are told to strive continuously to *be* the new man.
Is the Buddhist answer to let go of the new man too?
**Question with concrete example**
I have a thought about turning on the TV. The matters in that thought are not about giving up craving, not about mindfulness, not about being metta, so I give up the thought and don't look back at it.
Then I have a thought about doing well at a new job. Usually I have doubtful thoughts about the new job. The thought of working hard at the job I see as related to diligence. I do not give up the thought and entertain it.
Whereas the TV watcher is clearly not self - something that has arisen from a place that is not self - the thought of working hard at the job now feels like self. I am about the thought, the thought is about me. There is a self and the self is concerned with the thought.
I don't feel it's possible to overcome the sense of self without giving up the thought, and giving up the thought I don't feel is possible without the giving up of diligence. If someone suggested that you could have not-self AND thought entertainment, I think I would brush that off as them not speaking from experience.
Should I give up right diligence / right livelihood?
Gondola Spärde
(461 rep)
Nov 5, 2025, 06:29 AM
• Last activity: Nov 8, 2025, 06:22 AM
0
votes
2
answers
95
views
Uncertainty of matters in thoughts and certainty of breath
I wonder if Buddhism has a concept or teaching surrounding what is happening in my personal practice right now. In my practice right now I want to reduce my focus on things that are certain. It's certain that I am typing on my phone right now, and breathing in. Then a idea pops up of something relat...
I wonder if Buddhism has a concept or teaching surrounding what is happening in my personal practice right now.
In my practice right now I want to reduce my focus on things that are certain. It's certain that I am typing on my phone right now, and breathing in.
Then a idea pops up of something relating to the future, and I recognize the uncertainty around any theories surrounding the future.
Earlier I came up with theories about craving and other things, and recognized the uncertainty of any such theories. I had many theories about how the mind works in the past but now I see the uncertainty in these theories. I try to synthesize insights based on what I learned from Buddhism but I'm uncertain of the theories in the end.
Those mind theories I have are impermanent too, always changing and coming up with a new theory.
But now the only certainty is my thumbs hitting my phone.
Then a craving pops up and I'm led away from the certainty of breathing.
Is there anything surrounding certainty or uncertainty in Buddhism being taught?
Gondola Spärde
(461 rep)
Oct 19, 2025, 11:10 AM
• Last activity: Oct 29, 2025, 06:29 PM
2
votes
4
answers
2011
views
How can I stop speaking with others?
I am basically an undergraduate Student in a university in Asia. My classes started in the month of August 2025. Now before coming to college, I made my mind in such a way that I decided that I will not speak with others, but instead if anyone asks me anything, then I will reply. But after coming to...
I am basically an undergraduate Student in a university in Asia.
My classes started in the month of August 2025. Now before coming to college, I made my mind in such a way that I decided that I will not speak with others, but instead if anyone asks me anything, then I will reply.
But after coming to the college, my friends are repeatedly trying to speak with me and want to make me their friends. But I really don't want that. Not only the friends, but also the teachers of the university are also disturbing me repeatedly. I basically don't want to take the help of others, but the teachers are repeatedly asking me that if you have any questions then please ask.
I want to stay alone and silent. But the environment is not permitting to do that. Every time someone is always available to disturb me.
Please guide me how to get rid of these things. I want to know: How can I control myself?
Bachelor
(133 rep)
Sep 2, 2025, 06:29 PM
• Last activity: Oct 16, 2025, 11:12 AM
0
votes
3
answers
73
views
Can turning to scripture for guidance and answer be counter to Dhamma?
I find it reassuring to be able to turn to the pali suttas for answers. I happened across comments by users that disparage against turning to the suttas for answers, one describing how it makes one come off as "Buddha's teacher's pet". Some amount of ego-hurt, but also genuine curiousity, makes me q...
I find it reassuring to be able to turn to the pali suttas for answers.
I happened across comments by users that disparage against turning to the suttas for answers, one describing how it makes one come off as "Buddha's teacher's pet".
Some amount of ego-hurt, but also genuine curiousity, makes me question if turning to the suttas for advice and certainty could be counter to reaching attainments.
Would appreciate any perspective.
reign
(418 rep)
Oct 15, 2025, 06:42 PM
• Last activity: Oct 16, 2025, 07:06 AM
1
votes
3
answers
516
views
Does "manifestation" (visualization of success) lead to suffering?
[A sports article][1] says this > Do you want to take first place in an upcoming triathlon? Want to > break your personal record in swimming laps? Want to be faster than > your best friend in the pool? Whatever it is you want, visualize > yourself accomplishing it. Would buddhism condone such visual...
A sports article says this
> Do you want to take first place in an upcoming triathlon? Want to
> break your personal record in swimming laps? Want to be faster than
> your best friend in the pool? Whatever it is you want, visualize
> yourself accomplishing it.
Would buddhism condone such visualization of success?
reign
(418 rep)
Oct 13, 2025, 08:01 AM
• Last activity: Oct 14, 2025, 02:23 AM
Showing page 1 of 20 total questions