What do Protestants think about seeking "visitations" of the Holy Spirit in prayer, as taught by Seraphim of Sarov?
1
vote
0
answers
15
views
I'm reading *St. Seraphim of Sarov: On the Acquisition of the Holy Spirit (Conversation with Motovilov)* ([pdf](https://eeparchy.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2013/05/ST.-SERAPHIM-OF-SAROV-ON-THE-ACQUISITION-OF-THE-HOLY-SPIRIT-Conversation-with-Motovilov-.pdf)) . For context:
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seraphim_of_Sarov
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikolay_Motovilov
On pp. 5–6, Seraphim says (emphasis mine):
> "Your Godliness deigns to think it a great happiness to talk to poor
> Seraphim, believing that even he is not bereft of the grace of the
> Lord. What then shall we say of the Lord Himself, the never-failing
> source of every blessing both heavenly and earthly? Truly in prayer we
> are granted to converse with Him, our all-gracious and life-giving God
> and Savior Himself. **But even here we must pray only until God the
> Holy Spirit descends on us in measures of His heavenly grace known to
> Him**. **And when He deigns to visit us, we must stop praying**. Why
> should we then pray to Him, 'Come and abide in us and cleanse us from
> all impurity and save our souls, O Good One,' when He has already come
> to us to save us, who trust in Him, and truly call on His holy Name,
> that humbly and lovingly we may receive Him, the Comforter, in the
> mansions of our souls, hungering and thirsting for His coming?
>
> "I will explain this point to your Godliness through an example.
> **Imagine that you have invited me to pay you a visit, and at your invitation I come to have a talk with you**. But you continue to
> invite me, saying: 'Come in, please. Do come in!' Then I should be
> obliged to think: 'What is the matter with him? Is he out of his
> mind?'
>
> "So it is with regard to our Lord God the Holy Spirit. That is why it
> is said: Be still and know that I am God; I will be exalted among the
> nations. I will be exalted in the earth (Ps. 45:10). **That is, I
> will appear and will continue to appear to everyone who believes in Me
> and calls upon Me, and I will converse with him as once I conversed
> with Adam in Paradise, with Abraham and Jacob and other servants of
> Mine, with Moses and Job, and those like them.**
>
> Many explain that this stillness refers only to worldly matters; in
> other words, that during prayerful converse with God you must 'be
> still' with regard to worldly affairs. But I will tell you in the name
> of God that not only is it necessary to be dead to them at prayer, but
> **when by the omnipotent power of faith and prayer our Lord God the Holy**
> **Spirit condescends to visit us, and comes to us in the plenitude of**
> **His unutterable goodness**, we must be dead to prayer too.
>
> "The soul speaks and converses during prayer, **but at the descent of
> the Holy Spirit** we must remain in complete silence, in order to hear
> clearly and intelligibly all the words of eternal life which he will
> then deign to communicate. Complete soberness of soul and spirit, and
> chaste purity of body is required at the same time. The same demands
> were made at Mount Horeb, when the Israelites were told not even to
> touch their wives for three days before the appearance of God on Mount
> Sinai. For our God is a fire which consumes everything unclean, and no
> one who is defiled in body or spirit can enter into communion with
> Him."
As I understand it, Seraphim describes prayer as "inviting" the Holy Spirit, and teaches that when the Spirit "visits" in a special way, one should cease speaking (even cease verbal prayer) and attend in silence to what God communicates. This sounds mystical/contemplative, and also resembles some Pentecostal/charismatic language about experiencing the Spirit's presence.
How do Protestants generally evaluate this kind of pursuit? Specifically:
- Do Protestants believe Christians should *seek* special "visitations" or intensified experiences of the Holy Spirit during prayer, beyond the Spirit's ordinary indwelling?
- Would Protestants agree with the idea that, when such a visitation occurs, one should stop speaking and listen in silence for communication from the Spirit?
- Are there particular Protestant traditions (e.g., Reformed, Lutheran, Anglican, Baptist, Methodist, Pentecostal/charismatic) that would affirm or reject this, and on what biblical/theological grounds?
Asked by user117426
(764 rep)
Feb 13, 2026, 05:35 PM
Last activity: Feb 13, 2026, 08:38 PM
Last activity: Feb 13, 2026, 08:38 PM