Sample Header Ad - 728x90

What, precisely, is kamma/karma?

9 votes
6 answers
1387 views
In Buddhist doctrine there is always the problem, that for the sake of understandability, certain concepts are being presented in a solid, substantial way, while actually, one has to keep in the back of one's mind, that by the central tenet of *anattā*/*anātman* these concepts are **actually** not like that. The same applies to *kamma*/*karma*, which can be presented as **something** that a being accumulates and carries with itself in this life and to the next and the ones following. Now, actually, there is nothing substantial that transmigrates from one life to the next, as is clear from the similes that are used to explain rebirth without soul: a candle that lights another, an echo, a mirror image, the imprint in wax of seal. In these cases, though there is some link between the two sides, nothing actually goes from one to the other (the case with the echo should maybe be reconsidered according to the old Indian theories of sound and the echo). So, what is *kamma*/*karma*? How does it stick to the individual? To take this question one step further, if we admit now that *kamma*/*karma* is near-identical with the concept of *saṃskāra*/*saṃkhāra*, and therefore with volitions and *cetanā*, as in this quote from AN 6.63 : > cetanāhaṃ bhikkave kammaṃ vadāmi > > Intention, I tell you, is kamma and that by karmic unwholesome action the consciousness "leans towards" unwholesomeness, then how are these leanings supposed to look, how are they thought to be transported from one conscious moment to the next?
Asked by zwiebel (1604 rep)
Jun 18, 2014, 02:05 PM
Last activity: Oct 9, 2016, 05:58 AM