How is young-earth creationism theologically harmful, according to those who do not adhere to it?
15
votes
8
answers
4046
views
According to Young Earth Creationists, other beliefs (particularly in Evolutionism) harm Christianity in various ways such as:
- Making Death something other than the direct consequence of Sin
- Distorting the redemptive role of Death¹
- Denying the special value of man as distinct from all other creatures
- Reducing God's power
I don't want to belabor the point, as I'm merely trying to show the existence of claims that a denial of YEC is detrimental to Christian theology.
I also don't want to get into debates of whether belief in, or rejection of, YEC is beneficial or harmful to one's ability to *remain* in the faith. For this question, I am placing that explicitly out of bounds. (Likewise for arguments dealing with science, whether or not a belief is scientifically supported or affects one's view of science.)
Rather, given the above YEC arguments, it would seem that a case can be made that any attack on YEC is an attack on Christianity itself, and that all such attacks are thus ultimately opposed to Christianity. Indeed, such arguments *have* been made by various YECs.
Now... if such arguments can be sustained, they would be a powerful argument in favor of YEC. Therefore, I would like to explore the opposite side.
According to non-YECs, **what are the theological detriments to belief in YEC?**
----
(¹ Death is the wages/consequence of Sin. Adam sinned ⇒ God killed an animal. God's people sinned ⇒ they sacrificed animals. Humans sinned ⇒ God sacrificed His Son. YECs argue that death before sin distorts this relation and reduces the atoning "value" of death. [This answer](/a/41819/53502) on another question may be helpful.)
Asked by Matthew
(12382 rep)
Apr 7, 2022, 07:44 PM
Last activity: Jul 28, 2023, 09:41 PM
Last activity: Jul 28, 2023, 09:41 PM