Sample Header Ad - 728x90

Why is standing considered "more communal" than kneeling?

2 votes
1 answer
83 views
I asked catholic.chat this question already, and was unimpressed by the responses. Apparently the Cdl. Cupich gives for outlawing kneeling while receiving communion is that it is an act of Communal Worship to stand in line and receive communion while still standing, rather than stand in line and receive communion while kneeling (or before a communion rail shoulder to shoulder with your fellow (non-mortal) sinners). Catholic.chat said: > 1. **Posture of Unity**: Standing together as a congregation can symbolize a shared commitment and active participation in the worship experience. It visually represents the unity of the faithful as they approach the altar together, highlighting their collective identity as the Body of Christ. Kneeling, while also a posture of reverence, can sometimes create a more individual experience, as it may emphasize personal humility and devotion. > > 2. **Movement Together**: When the faithful stand and process forward to receive Communion, it emphasizes the communal journey of faith. This act of moving together in a line as one body can foster a sense of belonging and shared purpose. Kneeling, on the other hand, might not have the same dynamic of movement and collective action, as individuals may kneel at different times or in different ways. > > 3. **Joy and Celebration**: Standing can convey a sense of joy and celebration, which aligns with the nature of the Eucharist as a feast. This joyful aspect can enhance the communal atmosphere of the liturgy, inviting everyone to share in the experience together. Kneeling, while reverent, might evoke a more solemn or personal tone that could detract from the communal celebration. > >4. **Inclusivity**: Standing may also be more accessible for all members of the congregation, including those with physical limitations. This inclusivity can enhance the sense of community, ensuring that everyone can participate fully in the reception of Communion. Everything on this list could be argued that it is enhanced by kneeling while receiving communion. I know the Church is not a democracy, but it usually draws on the Natural Law for first principles and this is just seems completely backwards. It also seems like the Cardinal is stressing "Communion" as communion with the congregation over "Communion" as Communion with Christ. So, I can only assume there has to be a more striking and important reason for which we should overtly ban kneeling to receive Communion which strengthens our Communion with Christ or else this would be a patently evil move on the part of Cardinal Cupich, which I, or any Catholic, would be loathe to accuse him of. So why is standing considered more communal than kneeling?
Asked by Peter Turner (34456 rep)
Dec 17, 2024, 04:48 PM
Last activity: Dec 18, 2024, 04:55 PM