Is Tulku (Living Buddha)'s reincarnation process determined by its Karma or by Willpower(Praṇidhāna)?
1
vote
1
answer
64
views
This question is inspired by this online video :
A lady asked a Rinpoche 3 questions, that translate to (a bit complicated logics here):
> 1. Is Tulku's (Living Buddha)'s reincarnation process predetermined by his/her Karma(Karmaphala) or by Willpower(Praṇidhāna) ?
>
> Some explanations: Here she was actually asking, that by Buddhism doctrines, the *fact* that (bodhisattva) reincarnation will *happen* is result of Praṇidhāna, but is the *process* or *outcome* also determined by Praṇidhāna? Or like all other Sentients, that it is determined by Karmaphala?
>
> 2. If reincarnation is mainly determined by Karma, does a Tulku still have Karma? Why can bodhisattva still be affected and get life determined by
> Karmaphala? Shouldn't a Tulku be already liberated from (Karma-driven) Saṃsāra or at least have already purified his/her Karma in his first life?
>
> 3. If reincarnation is mainly determined by Praṇidhāna, why would next-generation Tulku still need to be selected, to study his/her
> knowledge before, to suffer from real-life setbacks? Why does his/her
> Praṇidhāna determine his/her life to be so?
In the video this Rinpoche said:
> 1. He believes he is mainly affected by Karma, but many other greater Tulkus believe reincarnation is determined by Praṇidhāna.
But he didn't explain why he or the others think so.
> 2. Either by Karma or by Praṇidhāna, the setbacks that real-life Tulkus meet (*e.g. forgetting many knowledge after
> reincarnation*) makes a Tulku more human-like, and that make people
> believe in him/her because people think Tulku and theirselves are equal.
I am confused on this too - shouldn't people believe in him/her more firmly if Tulku is more god-like? Like Jesus Christ revived and ascended, everyone saw this will believe in him.
I also asked Deepseek R1, it says something similar like the Rinpoche said in the video, plus
> Tulku can purify the Karma in their every new life in order to help achieve the Praṇidhāna will.
I think here Deepseek indicates, every reincarnation brings new karma. after reincarnation and before Karma is fully purified, a Tulku is still predetermined by Karmaphala.
Also I find a video from a much respected Taiwan Mahayana monk's view, Bodhisattva's reincarnation relies on both Praṇidhāna and Karmaphala . A Tulku is a Vajrayana Buddhist Lama who has taken the *bodhisattva vow*, but still different from Mahayana bodhisattva.
I believe this is an open, speculatve, theoretical question. I want to listen what more others think about this question, and think about the above Rinpoche's explanation. Any view is welcomed.
Asked by Cheshire_the_Maomao
(228 rep)
Feb 23, 2025, 05:47 PM
Last activity: Feb 24, 2025, 10:47 AM
Last activity: Feb 24, 2025, 10:47 AM