Questions about strong acceptance of rebirth?
1
vote
6
answers
263
views
In a nutshell, the Buddha's teaching is:
- self-views ("I have a self" and/or "I have no self") must be avoided
- craving is a precondition for suffering, thus we must train ourselves to gain control over craving and, finally, to eradicate it
- nihilism ("non existence") and/or existentialism ("existence") must be avoided
- being spiritual or having spiritual views is better than being materialistic or having materialistic views
- extremes must be avoided (middle way)
I'm wondering WHY a strong belief in rebirth does not conform with the above Buddha's teachings? I really want to understand the WHY behind it. WHY a belief in rebirth does not lead to the cessation of suffering? WHY somebody who **strongly accepts rebirth** (read the below case to see what I mean by "strongly accepting rebirth") can't attain Nibanna?
Please respond to the below questions that I provided and then if you wish give your explanations/answers.
*********
CASE a)
Suppose person X **STRONGLY ACCEPTS REBIRTH** by claiming: ***"There's NO WAY that after death there is no life. Life after death doesn't stop. Life after death is real. Life after death can't stop."*** When asked *"Can life after death come to an end for an arahat?"* person X would answer: *"No. There's NO WAY life after death can come to an end. Life after death does not come to an end for all beings, even if a being is an arahat or attained enlightenment (Nirvana).*". When asked "*Is there at least any tinyyyy possibility life after death can come to an end for an arahat?*" person X would answer: *"No. There's NO WAY! I know there's no way! NO WAY."*.
Suppose person X is very sturdy and close minded and there's no way person X will change his/her views about life after death, not even if somebody would threaten his/her life and would actually kill him/her.
Questions:
**1a.** Is strong acceptance of rebirth in the above scenario, a result of craving? Why?
**2a.** Is strong acceptance of rebirth in the above scenario, a result of nihilistic ("non existence") and/or eternalists ("existence") views? Why?
**3a.** Is strong acceptance of rebirth in the above scenario, a result of a view regarding self ("I have a self" and/or "I have no self")? Why?
**4a.** Can an arahat strongly accept rebirth, just like person X in the example above? Why?
Asked by beginner
(2679 rep)
Oct 8, 2017, 04:57 PM
Last activity: Oct 9, 2017, 10:57 PM
Last activity: Oct 9, 2017, 10:57 PM